2008-01-20 John 1:29-42
Defining (the) Moments: Named
James McTyre
Lake Hills Presbyterian Church (USA)
The next day John saw Jesus coming toward him and said, "Look, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!
They said, "Rabbi" (which means Teacher)...
"We have found the Messiah" (that is, the Christ).
If I were still in charge of the remote control - and I figure I’ve got about 15 years until it reverts back to its rightful owner (me) - I would probably never land on the show, “American Idol.” As a minister, its very title presents some pretty significant issues. Back when *I* was a boy... back when we still had sin... making someone or something an idol was a bad thing. Now we make TV shows about it, as well shows about avarice, gluttony, adultery and greed. Which are the ones I would watch, if I could ever get my hands on the remote.
Anyway, what was I talking about? “American Idol.” The new season began last week. My advice is, if you haven’t watched it, don’t. It’s joyful, cruel, uplifting, heartbreaking, and completely addictive - everything good TV ought to be.
In my opinion, the best weeks are the early ones, when pretty much anyone who can - or can’t - hold a tune gets to audition. Some of the auditions are fantastic. Normal people belt out a tune and you think, “Wow, how’d that voice come out of that average-looking person?” And, some of the auditions make you wonder if the people spend much time outside the house, or outside their shower where they must sound so much better.
Even though the people who don’t make the cut are often off-key, weird, or downright rude, my heart goes out to them. No one ever walks away saying, “Oh well. That’s how it goes.” No, they walk out flooding the floor with tears. Or saying bleepable things to the camera. Or calling themselves names like, loser. One girl in particular - the one dressed like Princess Leia from Star Wars - kept ranting about what a loser she was, telling her parents, telling the camera. Loser, loser, loser. (Actually, it was a different word, but we won’t get into that here.) If there are people who leave saying, “Oh well, at least Jesus still loves me,” Fox Network doesn’t show them.
The thing that makes the show tug so hard at the emotions is that - in the early weeks - it’s not the contestants’ singing ability that’s being judged. At least, that’s not the way the contestants seem to take it. What we see is people being judged. It’s as if they leave the auditions convinced that they, personally, are winners or losers, good people or bad people, blessed or cursed, because of how Simon, Randy and Paula judge them. How three people judge them - three - looks as though it’ll define the remainder of their lives.
We know the labels put on us when we’re kids often has incredible influence on us. A beloved teacher tells us, “You are the smartest student I’ve ever taught. You could make straight A’s if you wanted to,” and suddenly, we’re like the Scarecrow who realizes he has a brain. A coach says, “Boy, you are the sorriest excuse for a ball player I’ve ever seen,” and we quit the team. Our parents tell us by words or by actions we’re smart, we’re dumb, we’re important, we’re invisible, we’re worth the world, or we’re worthless - and it sticks. Maybe a bad review becomes the motivation to prove them wrong. Maybe it becomes confirmation of what we already suspect. How we are judged - how we think we’re judged even if we’re not told - has awesome, frightening power over who we are and who we might become. How we’re named, what we’re named, defines our moments.
---
Jesus walks past, and John the Baptist shouts after him, “Look, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!” His disciples call him, “Rabbi (which means teacher).” They talk about him when he’s not around and say, “We have found the Messiah” (that is, the Christ).
What would you think about yourself if someone heaped such superlatives on you? How would you handle such extreme compliments? You’d think, “This person is nuts.” But if everyone surrounding you twenty-four hours a day puffed your head full of such ideas, after a while, might you begin to think, just a little, like an “American Idol?” Might you begin to believe just enough to enjoy all the praise, especially if it came with fame, wealth and paparazzi? Might you start to behave like some of the fallen idols whose pictures are plastered all over the grocery store magazines? I’d surely hope not, but until we’re in that situation, how would we know?
Jesus simply walks down the street, and people start calling him names. In this case they’re good names. But a few verses later, they won’t be. Other people will be calling him plenty of names that aren’t nice at all.
We teach our kids the rhyme, “Sticks and stones may break my bones, but names will never hurt me.” We teach them that because we’re trying to protect them from the truth. Names are much, much more powerful than sticks and stones. If we believe them - and we do - names are infinitely more powerful than sticks and stones. Sticks and stones may break our bones, but names can break our spirits. Spoken at the right time by the right person, names can lift our spirits and change our lives in good and positive ways. Spoken in other times, in other ways, names can have tragic consequences. If you’ve ever been picked on or bullied, as a child or as an adult, you know how bad it can be.
So what does Jesus say when he’s called, in this case, good names - very, very good names? Does he say, “That’s right! You’re the winning contestant!” Does he say, “Who me? The Messiah? You’ve got to be kidding?” Does he ignore them?
No. Jesus says, “What do you want?” And then, a little later, “Come and see.”
When we’re called names - or worse, when we suspect we’re being called names, we usually react by agreeing (“They’re right, I am a loser”) or by disagreeing (“Oh yeah? I’ll show you”). It’s no surprise that Jesus is smarter than we are (something we tend to forget). Instead of agreeing or disagreeing with the names other people call him - even if they’re positive - Jesus asks, “What do you want?”
That’s else we tend to forget. Whenever anyone calls us a name - positive or negative - because they’re also human beings, what they’re saying about us is also saying something about them. Maybe they don’t want anything outright. Maybe they just want the thrill of being on the panel of judges for a minute. Maybe they want to make you feel bad so they can feel good. Maybe they want to feel less important by making you more important in their own minds than you really are. We hear praise or condemnation and we forget what Jesus knew, praisers or condemners almost always want something. Maybe it’s not your approval, maybe it’s their own personal need to be right in their judgments. Maybe they’re secretly saying, “Prove me right or prove me wrong. Just prove me.” Jesus asks, “What do you want?” and exposes the truth about human idolatry. We make people into idols in order to justify our own judgment. We make ourselves into idols in order to define who we are. We all know that if we believe we’re better than we really are, we’re turning ourselves into idols in our own minds. But it’s also true that if we believe we’re worse than we really are, we’re making negative idols out of ourselves, anti-idols we can throw emotional, or mental, or spiritual stones at. We do the same when we label others, too. We make them into idols, or anti-idols, in our minds. We set other people on pedestals we know don’t have the legs - or we bury them under the pedestals so we can walk on them. Idolatry cuts both ways. In any way, it distracts us from the real question, what is it, really, that we’re looking for?
The other answer Jesus gives the people naming him, is, “Come and see.” How lucky Jesus was that the disciples actually did. They followed him, and they saw living proof of who he was and how he lived. Unfortunately, we don’t have that luxury. People can’t follow us around in both our public and private moments to learn who we really, really are, instead of who we say we are, or who we believe we are. People usually only have a few moments to make their judgment as to whether we’re “winners” or “losers.” And we only have the same few moments to make the same decisions about them. The label or the name we place upon them, or they place upon us, is the shortcut to “Come and see.” The label is the idolatrous alternative to really, really getting to know each other.
Jesus sidesteps the idolatry of the people who would label him before they knew him. He invites them to follow him. And, blessing to them, they do.
It’s strange to think that we might make an idol of Jesus. But that’s what we do when we call him names without following him. We make an idol of Jesus when we make judgments about him - good or bad - without getting to know him, where he lives and how he behaves. We make an idol of Jesus when we use him as a tool to get what we want - approval of others, approval of ourselves - without becoming his follower in word and in deed.
The flipside of this is that we make idols of ourselves when we don’t let Jesus get to know us. Whenever we think we can get away with something because Jesus isn’t looking, we’re making an idol of ourselves. Whenever we think Jesus doesn’t know who we really are, we’re building an idolatrous little wall between us and him. Instead of hiding our sins from Jesus, we have to lay them down at his feet. We have to try living in his footsteps if we’re ever going to smash the idols of our own minds.
---
If you ever try out for American Idol, let us know. We’ll find someone with a big TV and pull for you. We’ll be the big cheering section they sometimes show of the friends back home. But if you ever do try out, please remember this: You are not defined as good or as bad by what three well-paid judges say about you. Nor are you defined even by how loudly we cheer for you. Instead, your moments - all your moments, not just the ones in the spotlight - ALL your moments are defined by Jesus Christ. All your moments are defined by Jesus Christ who calls you, good or bad, good AND bad, to follow him. Are you a winner or are you a loser? Truth be told, we’re all some of both. Whether you’re a winner or a loser really isn’t the important question. The important question is the one Jesus put to the disciples: “What are you looking for?” If you’re looking for Him, and if you’re willing to follow him, judgment falls by the wayside. If you’re looking for him and if you’re following him, you’re moving beyond judgment and idolatry; you’re defining yourself by faith. That’s when the question changes from “What are you looking for?” to “Who?” Who are you looking for? If it’s Jesus, are you willing to come and see? Are you willing to follow where he leads? Are you willing to know him as more than a winner or a loser, but as your Savior?